Debate: Should the Government Force Mega-RMDs on Massive Retirement Accounts?

Byrnes: If we read the fine print on these proposals, the new mandatory withdrawal rules would only apply to taxpayers earning over $400,000 for the year. We have to remember that many of America’s wealthiest taxpayers are asset-rich but actually earn very little income for ordinary income tax purposes. The limits are clearly just a political ploy for Biden to make it seem as though he’s increasing taxes on the wealthy and limiting tax-avoidance loopholes. 

Bloink: Retirement accounts are given such valuable tax preferences to encourage ordinary Americans to save for their own retirements. Instead, the wealthiest Americans are often using these accounts, especially Roth accounts, to pass wealth to future generations without tax liability on their accumulations during life — and, in some cases, even post-mortem. That’s simply not why we give people these tax-preferred savings options.

Byrnes: In reality, the rules may have very little impact on the wealthiest taxpayers. Instead, they could serve to discourage Americans from investing in their own retirement — because if the investments they make within their retirement accounts happen to become wildly successful, they’ll be punished with immediate tax liability.

Bloink: The bottom line is that excessive retirement account accumulations function as a tax loophole that we should want to close. We want to encourage strong and robust retirement savings, of course, but there comes a point where the system becomes abusive. Biden’s plan targets only excessive accumulations and would merely require the wealthy to actually pay taxes on their accumulations like any hard-working American.

Byrnes: Retirement savers have no way to conclusively predict how successful their retirement account investments will become. This entire debate began because of the highly publicized success of Peter Thiel’s investments within Roth accounts. Those investments were largely available to all taxpayers. Punishing taxpayers for the success of their investment strategies is no way to encourage those taxpayers to invest in our economy — whether through tax-preferred retirement accounts or otherwise.

• Learn more with Tax Facts, the go-to resource that answers critical tax questions with the latest tax developments. Online subscribers get access to exclusive e-newsletters.
• Discover more resources on finance and taxes on the NU Resource Center.
• Follow Tax Facts on LinkedIn and join the conversation on financial planning and targeted tax topics.
• Get 10% off any Tax Facts product just for being a ThinkAdvisor reader! Complete the free trial form or call 859-692-2205 to learn more or get started today.