The ten Greatest Mascaras of 2024, Examined and Reviewed by Editors

“I naturally have lengthy, darkish lashes that I additional improve with lash serums. Nevertheless, they’re very straight and susceptible to droopiness. Due to this fact, curling my lashes pre-mascara is nonnegotiable for me. My dream mascara offers me sufficient quantity on the root to make my lash line look thicker with out trying clumpy or too thick on the high. General, I desire a mascara that retains my lashes lifted and curled and supplies numerous fluttery size and definition. I are likely to desire small, versatile rubber brushes, versus huge, bushy ones, since they offer me extra management and really feel much less heavy and moist on my lashes. Primarily, I wish to seem like Bambi! My mascara deal-breakers: a components that’s too heavy or moist (thus sabotaging curl and elevate), transfers, or smudges.” — Erin Jahns

“My lashes are lengthy however pin-straight, so I am all the time in search of a mascara that makes them look lifted and outlined. My dream mascara could be one thing that provides size and quantity. It might have an inky black components, nevertheless it would not deposit an excessive amount of product on my lashes. It might look pure and be extraordinarily buildable. Additionally, there could be no smudging—so many mascaras smudge! My mascara deal-breakers: smudging, flaking, or a components that is too heavy and offers my lashes a spidery impact.” — Kaitlyn McLintock

“My lashes are pretty common! Not too lengthy, not too quick, not tremendous thick. I by no means really feel like I want mascara once I exit. My eyelashes aren’t nonexistent, however I all the time do put on it once I wish to do a full make-up look. My dream mascara is a non-clumpy components that makes my eyelashes look fluffy and lengthy. My mascara deal-breakers: I completely hate when a mascara clumps my lashes collectively. Quantity, to me, should not imply clumpy! And do not get me began on smudging. Once I finish the day trying like a raccoon, I do know it is dangerous.” — Anneliese Dominguez

“My lashes are skinny, blonde, and the sort that stick straight out, so an eyelash roller is a should for me. They don’t have any pure quantity, so I rely closely on an excellent mascara to reinforce them. My dream mascara retains my straight lashes lifted all through the day. I need my mascara to make it seem like I’ve had a lash elevate and tint with out paying for one! My mascara deal-breakers: I desire a extra pure make-up look, so any mascara that clumps instantly will get tossed. I would moderately go mascara-less than take care of one which deposits an excessive amount of black goop onto my lashes.” — Natalie Grey Herder