REVIEW: Peanut Butter Oreo Cakesters (2024)

What’s a Cakester precisely? Is it:

A. a baker of sweets?
B. a reputation that 90’s bullies would yell at portly youngsters?
C. a soft-baked Oreo cookie?
D. a portmanteau of “cake” and “gangster?”

When you guessed “D,” you’re right. “Cakesters” are lackeys within the cake mafia. You would possibly know them because the “Slob Mob.” Cakesters work underneath the Don who goes by the identify “Cake Boss.” Yeah, I’m on to you, Valastro. That man is NOT our Buddy. Once you hear him speaking about “icing,” it ain’t about fondant.

Alright, when you guessed “C,” you’re additionally proper, however now you realize the clear inspiration for the identify.

Oreo Cakesters got here again in 2022, and now the peanut butter flavored crème model has returned. These are primarily simply snack muffins with an Oreo nametag. They’re constructed like Oreos however it’s a wholly completely different expertise. I’ve by no means even actually thought they tasted an excessive amount of like Oreos. Truthfully, these might have any snack cake branding, so that you’re most likely questioning in the event that they stack as much as the large canine within the snack cake enviornment?

Yeah, I believe these are proper according to Hostess, Drake’s, Tastykakes and Little Debbie.

They style like a barely worse patty-shaped model of my all-time favourite, the Satan Canine. I’ve all the time most popular a snack cake that isn’t slathered in a sheet of plasticized chocolate.

The cake is a little bit denser than the everyday, however it’s good as a result of it helps emulate an Oreo a little bit higher that manner. Taste-wise, the chocolate tastes vaguely like Oreo wafers at finest, however it’s nonetheless high quality.

The peanut butter filling could be very good texturally. It’s not Oreo crème, it’s extra whipped to raised match the snack cake norm. I assume a part of me is all the time upset by that. I’d kinda prefer to strive that gritty Oreo crème between two muffins, however I like this too.

Taste-wise, I’ve to say the crème is a little bit too gentle. There are some bites the place you don’t even actually register the peanut butter. It will get swallowed up by the chocolate cake.

I needed the peanut butter to punch me within the face like one in all Buddy’s Cakesters while you don’t have his flour. (That’s what they name cash… and likewise flour. It will get complicated.)

Right here’s the factor although, peanut butter crème snack muffins are likely to lean towards an artificial pb taste. Consider Humorous Bones for instance – I’ve by no means been an enormous fan of that peanut butter, and I really feel like that’s the usual. These are higher than Humorous Bones.

In the end, I believe unique Cakesters are superior to those, however I most likely like these a little bit higher than common overrated Peanut Butter Oreos. They’re satisfying if not a little bit boring, however nonetheless effectively value a purchase order. Peanut Butter Cakesters mainly land smack in the course of your complete Oreo product scale AND the snack cake scale.

Talking of scales, I don’t wanna sleep with the fishes, so when you’re studying this, I used to be simply messing round earlier, Mr. Valastro.

Bought Value: $4.19
Dimension: 10.1 oz package deal (5 2.02 oz packs)
Bought at: Store Ceremony
Ranking: 6 out of 10
Diet Details: (1 Pack) 260 energy, 13 grams of fats, 5 grams of saturated fats, 0 gram of trans fats, 5 milligrams of ldl cholesterol, 260 milligrams of sodium, 34 grams of carbohydrates, 2 grams of fiber, 20 grams of sugar, and 4 grams of protein.

Associated